Publishers and Authors Guild File Lawsuit Against State of Idaho For Discriminatory Book-banning Provisions with House Bill 710
Libraries, librarians and educators are punished by HB710 for having award-winning books and classics on public and school library shelves
Lawsuit follows recent legal action in Florida by Penguin Random House, Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins Publishers, Macmillan Publishers, Simon & Schuster, and Sourcebooks
(New York, February 4, 2025)—Penguin Random House, alongside Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins Publishers, Macmillan Publishers, Simon & Schuster, and Sourcebooks, have filed a lawsuit challenging the book removal provisions of HB 710, a law that restricts books in both public and school libraries in Idaho and was enacted into law on July 1, 2024. The additional plaintiffs joining the publishers are the Authors Guild, bestselling authors Malinda Lo, David Levithan, and Dashka Slater, the Donnelly Public Library District, a teacher, two students, and two parent plaintiffs.
HB 710 forbids anyone under age 18 from accessing library books that contain “sexual content,” regardless of the work’s literary or educational merit. HB710’s definition of sexual content is exceptionally broad, vague, and overtly discriminatory.
The ban extends to classics such as Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five, Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye, Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, and Maya Angelou’s I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings; and bestsellers including Game of Thrones by George R.R. Martin, I’ll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson, The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky, and Forever. . . by Judy Blume. HB 710 impacts nonfiction as well, imperiling access to factual resources such as The “What’s Happening to My Body?” Book for Girls by Lynda Madaras, and erasing history by removing books about the Holocaust and other historical events. The law makes no distinction between infants and 17-year-olds—books are classified as harmful regardless of the age and maturity level of the child.
Under the law, picture books such as Alexandra Penfold and Suzanne Kaufman’s All Are Welcome—which celebrates students from diverse backgrounds and depicts two dads walking down the street arm
in arm as they take their young child to school—would be deemed “harmful for minors” and removed from shelves.
The law not only allows county prosecuting attorneys and the state attorney general to bring claims against any school or public library—it also uniquely incentivizes private citizens to file legal complaints against public libraries or schools through a bounty system. Many libraries, including those in rural areas that are the sole book providers in their communities, cannot afford to be sued because they cannot cover the cost of a defense.
This legal threat has resulted in a chilling effect across the state, with libraries preemptively removing hundreds of books from their shelves. Some libraries have been forced to ban minors from their premises entirely because they are too small to segregate “adult” books. One such case is the Donnelly Public Library, a plaintiff in the lawsuit, which has restricted access to its building for anyone under 18 unless they are accompanied by a parent or guardian.
“Libraries should be for everyone. We foster learning, provide resources, inspire creativity, and support our patrons,” said Sherry Scheline, Director, Donnelly Public Library. “As a result of HB 710, our programming—which includes the only option for after-school care in Donnelly—has been severely impacted, with children unable to step inside the building to use the bathroom or keep warm without a complex waiver. Our circulation has also declined significantly. In essence, it has become impossible to fulfill our purpose of serving the Donnelly community.”
“Idaho 710 goes even further than previous laws by removing classic books from public libraries in addition to schools,” said Dan Novack, VP, Associate General Counsel at Penguin Random House. “Make no mistake, book bans are real and their damage is profound. We are honored to support the brave Idahoans challenging this dangerous law. This is the third state-level challenge our publisher-led coalition has filed, demonstrating our shared commitment to protecting the First Amendment rights of authors, educators, readers, and all Americans.”
According to Michael Grygiel, an adjunct faculty member with Cornell Law School’s First Amendment Clinic, “HB 710 has resulted in the removal of classic works of literature from library shelves across Idaho as libraries attempt to protect themselves from liability under the law’s vague and overbroad provisions. This type of self-censorship is inimical to First Amendment liberties and has suffocated the right of Idaho students to read books deemed appropriate for their age and maturity level by their parents. In short, the law is an affront to the Constitution. It is a privilege to represent the publishers, authors, libraries, parents, and students who have joined this lawsuit to challenge HB 710 and stand up for the First Amendment rights of all Idaho citizens.”
The plaintiffs are represented by the Cornell Law School First Amendment Clinic, with support from affiliated attorney Michael Grygiel, Stanton Fellow Daniela del Rosario Wertheimer, and Deborah Ferguson of Ferguson Durham PLLC.
The lawsuit follows recent legal actions by Penguin Random House, Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins Publishers, Macmillan Publishers, Simon & Schuster, and Sourcebooks against Iowa and Florida public officials, challenging the book-banning provisions of Senate File 496 (SF496) and House Bill 1069 (HB 1069) respectively. Penguin Random House is also a plaintiff in a lawsuit filed with PEN America against the Escambia County (Florida) School District over books that have been unconstitutionally removed.
Contacts:
Claire von Schilling, EVP & Director, Corporate Communications & Social Responsibility
Penguin Random House | cvonschilling@penguinrandomhouse.com
Dominique Cimina, SVP & Director, Publicity, Corporate Communications, & Author Brand Strategy
Random House Children’s Books | dcimina@penguinrandomhouse.com
Penguin Random House creates books for everyone. We believe books change us, connect us, and carry us toward a better future. As the world’s largest trade publisher, we reach readers in more than 175 countries with stories and ideas across the spectrum of viewpoints and experiences. Each year, we publish more than 18,000 new titles spanning fiction and nonfiction for readers of all ages and in all print, digital, and audio formats. Penguin Random House is a proud home to the world’s most influential voices, thinkers, and storytellers, including more than 80 Nobel Prize laureates, 140 U.S. Pulitzer Prizes, 20 National Book Awards, and 24 UK Booker Award winners. As fierce champions for free expression and expanding access to books, we celebrate the right to read, think, and learn. Every day we strive to build a more equitable, inclusive, and sustainable world. With businesses in more than 20 countries, Penguin Random House was formed in 2013 and has been solely owned by Bertelsmann since 2020.
The Cornell Law School First Amendment Clinic defends the free speech rights of clients across the political spectrum and the free press rights of local media outlets and freelance journalists. The Clinic’s Local Journalism Project protects, defends and enables journalists to play their critical function of informing the public. At its core, the Clinic seeks to further First Amendment rights to foster a better functioning and more robust democracy.
HarperCollins Publishers is the second largest consumer book publisher in the world, with operations in 15 countries. With more than 200 years of history and 120+ branded imprints around the world, HarperCollins publishes approximately 10,000 new books every year in 16 languages and has a print and digital catalog of more than 200,000 titles. Writing across dozens of genres, HarperCollins authors include winners of the Nobel Prize, the Pulitzer Prize, the National Book Award, the Newbery and Caldecott Medals, and the Man Booker Prize. HarperCollins, headquartered in New York, is a subsidiary of News Corp (Nasdaq: NWS, NWSA; ASX: NWS, NWSLV) and can be visited online at corporate.harpercollins.com.
Hachette Book Group
Hachette Book Group (HBG) is a leading US general-interest book publisher made up of dozens of esteemed imprints within the publishing groups Basic Books Group, Grand Central Publishing Group, Hachette Audio, Little, Brown and Company, Little, Brown Books for Young Readers, Orbit, Union Square & Co., and Workman Running Press Group. We also provide custom distribution, fulfillment, and sales services to other publishing companies. Our books and authors have received the Pulitzer Prize, National Book Award, Caldecott Medal, Newbery Medal, Booker Prize, Nobel Peace Prize and other major honors.
We are committed to diversity in our company and our publishing programs, and to fostering a culture of inclusion for all our employees and authors. We are proud to be part of Hachette Livre, the world’s third-largest trade and educational publisher. Visit hachettebookgroup.com to learn more about HBG imprints. For updated news follow HBG on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Threads, TikTok, X.com, and YouTube.
Macmillan Publishers is the U.S. trade company that is part of the Holtzbrinck Publishing Group, a large family-owned group of media companies headquartered in Stuttgart, Germany. Holtzbrinck Publishing Group’s publishing companies include prominent imprints around the world that publish a broad range of award-winning books for children and adults in all categories and formats.
U.S. publishers include Celadon Books, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, Flatiron Books, Henry Holt & Company, Macmillan Audio, Macmillan Children’s Publishing Group, The St. Martin’s Publishing Group, and Tor Publishing Group. In the UK, Australia, India, and South Africa, companies in the Holtzbrinck Publishing Group publish under the Pan Macmillan name. The German publishing company, Holtzbrinck Deutsche Buchverlage, includes among its imprints S. Fischer, Kiepenheuer & Witsch, Rowohlt, and Droemer Knaur. us.macmillan.com
Simon & Schuster, a global leader in general interest publishing, is dedicated to providing the best in fiction and nonfiction for readers of all ages, and in all printed, digital and audio formats. Its distinguished roster of authors includes many of the world’s most popular and widely recognized writers, and winners of the most prestigious literary honors and awards. It is home to numerous well-known imprints and divisions such as Simon & Schuster, Scribner, Atria Books, Gallery Books, Adams Media, Avid Reader Press, Simon & Schuster
Children’s Publishing and Simon & Schuster Audio and international companies in Australia, Canada, India, the United Kingdom, and VBK in the Netherlands and Belgium. It proudly brings the works of its authors to readers in more than 200 countries and territories. For more information visit our website at www.simonandschuster.com.
Sourcebooks is a thriving entrepreneurial company that brings extraordinary authors to readers in dynamic, data-driven ways. We create books that transcend categories and defy odds, and we have been honored with hundreds of national bestsellers and awards. We are a company of enthusiastic book lovers passionate about connecting books to readers in new and innovative ways. Story by story, book by book, we have changed more than 300 million lives. Join us as we change 300 million more.
The Authors Guild is the nation’s oldest and largest professional organization for published writers in the United States with nearly 15,000 members. It is dedicated to advocating for authors’ rights, fair pay, and free expression. It protects writers against challenges such as censorship, book bans, the misuse of AI, and nonpayment. It offers resources, legal support, and a professional community to help authors sustain their careers and thrive in an evolving literary landscape.
The Authors Guild Foundation is the charitable arm that supports the Guild’s work. It strengthens the Guild’s efforts to combat book bans, advocate for free expression, and champion writers’ rights. Additionally, the Foundation expands access to educational programs and literary events, connecting writers and readers through initiatives like the WIT Literary Festival and public talks. Together, they safeguard writers, defend free expression, and make literature accessible for everyone.
Malinda Lo is a New York Times bestselling author. She has written seven novels featuring queer female characters. Her works have appeared on many best-of lists, including the ALA’s Best Fiction for Young Adults, the ALA’s Rainbow Book List, Bank Street College’s Best Children’s Books of the Year, the Locus Recommended Reading List, and the James Tiptree Jr. Longlist. Lo’s novel Last Night at the Telegraph Club, about a Chinese American girl in 1950s San Francisco who discovers her identity as a lesbian, won multiple awards, including the National Book Award and a Stonewall Book Award. Malinda resides in Massachusetts.
David Levithan is the author of many bestselling YA novels featuring LGBTQ+ characters, including Boy Meets Boy, Two Boys Kissing, and Every Day. His work has won several prestigious awards, including the Indies Choice Book Awards Honor Award, three Lambda Literary Awards, two Stonewall Book Awards Honors, the National Council of Teachers of English’s Assembly on Literature for Adolescents Award, and the ALA’s Margaret A. Edwards Award for lasting contribution to young adult literature. David resides in New Jersey.
Dashka Slater is an author and journalist who has received numerous prestigious awards, including the ALA’s Stonewall Book Award, the Boston Globe-Horn Book Honor Award for Nonfiction, the California Library Association’s John and Patricia Beatty Award, and the Wanda Gág Read Aloud Book Award. Her writing aims to spark important conversations and provide young people with the tools to engage with complex social issues, such as transgender identity, racism, and criminal justice. Dashka resides in California.